
A private hospital has apologised to a patient and her family after a doctor mistakenly removed a woman’s ovaries during an operation.
CUHK Medical Centre. Photo: 水浪/Google Maps.Chung Kin-lai, chief executive officer of the Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK) Medical Centre, said during a press conference on Wednesday that the doctor involved was an experienced contract obstetrician and gynaecologist resident.
The doctor admitted the incident was due to mistakes during a phone call with Chung on the day the operation was conducted, Chung said.
The hospital did not disclose the name of the doctor or details of any disciplinary action, but said it would impose disciplinary actions in accordance with our human resources policies.
The CEO sent apologies to the patient, her family and to the public. He added that the patient is in stable condition and will be provided free follow-up appointments.
The Department of Health said on Tuesday in its regular update of medical sentinel event that a 45-year-old female patient’s bilateral ovaries were mistakenly and inadvertently removed in mid-September.
The Department of Health. File photo: GovHK.The patient was scheduled for laparoscopic hysterectomy and bilateral salpingectomy surgery – the removal of all or part of the uterus, and the removal of both fallopian tubes – in a private hospital.
The CUHK Medical Centre said in a press release on Tuesday that prior to the operation, both the surgical consent form and the original surgical plan clearly specified the preservation of both ovaries.
“After the surgical specimens were extracted, during the routine verification of the specimens, a nurse discovered that the bilateral ovaries were included,” the statement read.
“The nurse immediately notified the doctor of this discrepancy, as it deviated from the original surgical plan to preserve the ovaries.”
‘Cognitive blindspot’
The hospital’s Chinese version of the statement draw criticism over its description that the doctor had “a cognitive blindspot” during the operation and therefore “failed to carry out the original surgical plan of preserving the ovaries.”
Online, people left comments saying that the hospital was just playing with words to gloss over medical malpractice.
CUHK Medical Centre, a new private hospital opened in 2021. Photo: Wai Ki Wong/Google Maps.Chung said on Wednesday that the Chinese statement, which followed the English one, was poorly translated. The English statement said the doctor had a “temporary collapse of his situational awareness.”
“Put simply, the doctor involved had a lapse in concentration at the time,” Chung said in Cantonese.
The private hospital said it “candidly disclosed” the situation to the patient and her family and offered sincere apologies immediately after the malpractice took place on September 12.
It also informed the Department of Health about the incident within 24 hours and established a Root Cause Analysis Panel to conduct a comprehensive investigation.

English (US) ·